Since my last post regarding the disutility of coronary CT angiograms for the evaluation of acute chest pain in the Emergency Department was so popular, here’s more: a randomized trial testing CCTA versus stress echocardiogram.
The problem: no specific functional or anatomic testing is routinely necessary in the ED.
And, hidden in this comparison are broad results typical of testing in a “low to intermediate” population with a Diamond-Forrester pre-test probability of 28% and a TIMI score of 0 to 1. Effectively, it’s unimportant to describe their comparison because the incidence of their safety outcomes over a median follow-up of 733 days is so low its virtually impossible to detect a difference. Any Major Adverse Cardiovascular Event occurred in only 4.5% of all patients – but, restricted to the endpoints relevant to the testing performed, only 3.0% had a nonfatal myocardial infarction or cardiac arrest. Any differences in throughput and resource utilization between arms will be related to specific process and protocol implementation unique to the trial institution, so even their findings with respect to their primary outcome are not likely to be generalizable.
But, back to the futility of any test – only 10% of those enrolled were referred for cardiac catheterization, and only half of those received an intervention as a result. Another 10% or so received new or increased pharmacotherapy – likely overlapping with the population undergoing catheterization. Therefore, probably 85% of patients enrolled clearly received no specific benefit from these tests, 5% probably had some benefit, 5% were harmed (excess revascularization, serious complications), and 5% are equivocal.
And, all of this on the foundational premise these tests need to be performed widely, and in the ED. True disease is rare in this population, and the timeliness of diagnosis of CAD does not need to be made at the index visit. This is not high-value medical care.
“Coronary Computed Tomography Angiography Versus Stress Echocardiography in Acute Chest Pain: A Randomized Controlled Trial”